AISLE SAY Toronto

THE AUTUMN GARDEN

by Lillian Hellman
Directed by David Jones
Starring Elizabeth Franz John Benjamin Hickey, Allison Janney
Williamstown Theatre Festival
Williamstown, MA (413) 597-3400

Reviewed by Joel Greenberg

The Williamstown Festival boasts an exceptionally full season and extends beyond the confines of late spring-early fall. With the outstanding new facility in operation, including parking garage (too small and in need of staff to re-direct harried audience members to alternative options), the campus of Williams College feels more alive and filled with energy than I’ve experienced before. And I think this says a lot because the median age of the audience that I was in to see the matinee performance of The Autumn Garden was not a sign that younger audiences know or care about live theatre.

The largest of the three venues, where the Hellman play was produced, is a real gem. Sight lines are so comfortable, so totally designed to bring audience and performer into the same world. I only wish that I had enjoyed the performance as much.

Hellman’s play, first produced on Broadway in 1951, doesn’t share the dramatic power of The Children’s Hour or The Little Foxes. Rather, Hellman sought to create a world more Chekhovian, which is to say more defined by character than by plot or overriding theme. The result is a play that takes its own good time (and ours) to find its way. Whether or not it was the particular performance I saw (matinee following opening night), I can’t say. But the pace was so determinedly slow and the text itself so self-consciously ruminative, that the second intermission felt like one too many.

The large company of twelve actors had not yet established its own rhythms and there was no momentum to or from moments of insight or revelation. Hellman’s pattern of lives intersecting without being force-fed felt self-conscious and engineered.

Of the company itself, John Benjamin Hickey was always fascinating. Never predictable in his responses, he brought the world of the play to life with each of his scenes. Elizabeth Franz brought strength and tenacity, cut with acid humour, to an underwritten role. Maryann Plunkett wisely resisted condescension in her portrayal of a scattered wife (and managed to define the only credible three-dimensional character). Allison Janney, playing an ageing woman whose emotional life has been sacrificed or appropriated (you decide which) by southern provincialism, was gracious, if surprisingly muted.

The Autumn Garden is not an important play, but it is important that Williamstown can afford to include a minor play by a major writer in its season. In a culture that seems focused only on “the best”, where box office sales lead the headlines and where “names” sell art no less than deodorant or garbage bags, it is essential to foster and support Williamstown and, as much, companies with far less to work with.

Return to Home Page